December 9, 2023

Credit to Stephen Miller who saw this before I did. Today Rep. Rashida Tlaib posted a video whose main message was that progressives are not with President Biden and will remember his decision to side with Israel in 2024. Included in the video are a bunch of clips of pro-Palestinian protests from different places around the US. At protests in Michigan, people are seen chanting “From the river to the sea!” (1:05 below)


This slogan is widely interpreted as a call for the eradication of Israel since the land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea is primarily Israel as Sen. Kyrsten Sinema just pointed out:

This phrase is also a direct reference to terrorist group Hamas which uses this phrase in its constitution.

Hamas, whose gunmen killed 1,400 people on 7 October, claim the slogan in their rejection of Israel.

“Hamas rejects any alternative to the full and complete liberation of Palestine, from the river to the sea,” says the organisation’s 2017 constitution.

Liberation of Palestine in this context means the eradication of Israel. A Labour Party MP was just suspended from the party for paraphrasing the statement:

“We won’t rest until we have justice, until all people, Israelis and Palestinians, between the river and the sea can live in peaceful liberty,” said Andy McDonald, a Labour MP, at a protest in London organised by the Palestine Solidarity Campaign at the weekend.

Three days later, McDonald was suspended from the party pending an investigation, leaving the former shadow cabinet minister sitting as an independent for now.


This isn’t the only problem with the video. The clip includes a montage of Israeli airstrikes and with those is video of an explosion at al-Ahli Hospital in Gaza (0:07 seconds in the clip). As you probably know, independent experts and US intelligence officials concluded that explosion was not caused by an Israeli airstrike but was almost certainly the result of a misfired Hamas rocket:

Speaking to reporters by phone, the intelligence officials said they had “high confidence” in their assessment that it was not Israel that fired the rocket, but they were less certain which Palestinian militants fired the projectile on the evening of Oct. 17.

“We assess with high confidence that Israel was not responsible for the explosion at the hospital and that Palestinian militants were responsible,” an intelligence official said. “We assess with low confidence that Palestine Islamic Jihad was responsible for launching the rocket that landed on the hospital.”…

The evidence pointing to PIJ was based on intercepted conversations between suspected “Hamas affiliated militants” who appeared to be speculating about who was behind the rocket launch, the officials said…

The audio was not the same as that released publicly by Israel’s military previously, and it was vetted and deemed authentic, the official said.

In the context of the clip, Rep. Tlaib is clearly insinuating that Israel was responsible for the explosion at the hospital, ignoring the evidence that’s not what happened.


As for her central claim that Americans don’t support Biden’s handling of this, that may be true but Americans do support Israel.

…most Americans side with Israel in the conflict, according to the polls. The exact numbers vary widely, but across five recent polls, between three and five times as many Americans said they sympathized with Israelis than said they sympathized with Palestinians…

Not only do Americans support the Israeli government’s response, but they also want their own government to come to Israel’s aid. Seventy-one percent of Americans told YouGov/The Economist that protecting Israel was a very or somewhat important U.S. policy goal. And Quinnipiac University’s Oct. 12-16 survey found that 76 percent of registered voters thought supporting Israel was in the U.S. national interest.

All in all, a pretty incendiary and inaccurate post from Rep. Tlaib.